Mordhau
 λdambomb
Knight
  • Likes received 79
  • Date joined 20 Aug '17
  • Last seen 20 Sep '19

Private Message

Mercenary 1897 7067
  • 14 Oct '17
 ThunderDuck

@DrEpochノಥ益ಥノ said:

@Frise said:
Are you not capable of logical thinking? The hype of alpha release is gone for most people, and they have shit to do and games to play. That doesn't mean the game is dying.

And the combat isn't broken, you just completely fail to understand it, and complain about every fucking thing that kills you. Grow up please.

all i've done is ask a question

No you also said the game is broken (from your factual and totally objective point of view). Every time you post I see nothing but bitching and whining. From the videos you post it's pretty obvious that you are, no offense, pretty awful at the game. That is fine of course, but the reason you're never gonna get good is your whiny attitude. You're the type of guy who goes "that's just bullshit!" instead of "wow, i gotta figure out how to deal with that!" after every death and thus end up never improving.

301 875
  • 13 Oct '17
 Naleaus

There are a whole bunch of these threads, stop making more. The alpha is fine, the game is on the right track. An alpha does not need 3000 players to test. Once the next patch drops, player counts will rise again then. Then drop a few days after. Repeat till more game modes. This is normal, stop sensationalizing stuff.

Baron 725 1307
  • 2
  • 13 Oct '17
 NewYariMeta

@DrEpochノಥ益ಥノ said:
Combat is stale and whether some players like it or not. completely broken.

It's not, even without perks or a proper stam system implemented yet the combat is already deeper than chiv.

I know most people and ppl from chiv are going to rage hearing this. But facts are facts.

The fact is your just garbage son.

https://clips.twitch.tv/RelentlessBrainyAlfalfaSuperVinlin

Yes i definitely trust your opinion on the game over people who have thousands of hours in chiv and m&b comp.

Knight 528 3386
  • 13 Oct '17
 rob_owner

Your question assumes the issue is an issue without first making a convincing argument to show that the issue is an issue. You just kinda say it is and then imply it is by asking how to fix the implied issue.

Sellsword 172 430
  • 13 Oct '17
 Pencilman

It's an Alpha, not a full release. Take a seat.

Duke 162 274
  • 1
  • 13 Oct '17
 BEACHES

It's an alpha with 3,000 people across the globe.

Maybe 1,250 of those are US, 1,250 Euro, 500 other.

You're lucky to have 10-20 on at once with those numbers people have lives.....

On top of that it's unfinished. I'm not grinding an unfinished game 3-4 hours a day....

Knight 1269 3811
  • 13 Oct '17
 Frise

Are you not capable of logical thinking? The hype of alpha release is gone for most people, and they have shit to do and games to play. That doesn't mean the game is dying.

And the combat isn't broken, you just completely fail to understand it, and complain about every fucking thing that kills you. Grow up please.

Conscript 4564 6302
  • 2
  • 13 Oct '17
 vanguard

Sensationalist thread tittle tbh. How is it possible that the game is dying, if it isn't even for selling yet?

Most of the testers got bored or got rekt really hard, which tbh was kinda expected imho. These people will get back in later moments, once the game is more flashed out.

As a concept the combat is more then fine, it's genius imho. The execution needs a bit more work, and they are working on it with the new animations and shit. I don't see how this could be dead. Haven't even been born yet.

Countess 1233 2912
  • 13 Oct '17
 Whisper

Epoch do me.. do us a favor and just shut up. It's still early alpha, and you are like a gnat in my ear, that I can't swipe at fucking midnight.

Duchess 6897 9885
  • 13 Oct '17
 Sir Zombie

And what you are saying is an opinion
There aren't a lot of people playing because there aren't a lot that can play

Knight 24 107
Knight 2 8
  • 26 Sep '17
 Earl of Sandwich

Am bad plz help, for I possess none of the time resource, ty glhf, plz don't ban cause (I) am bad, (I) understand that I am bad(I think I get chamber{ing} concepts),but,{clash concepts am(ARE FUCKING) weird} [note: most of you know I am bad from: chiv/ and/or jkII, and/or jkIII, and/or worse(plz feel free to extrapolate from incomplete data ), basically I will fight you to the death every time (or back off if a teammate is more zealous than I): or you will slay me in 2 hits or less. Thank you for your time noble persons.

Knight 3313 6811
  • 25 Sep '17
 Bodkin

The discussion got to plenty of places, you just aren't fond of those places because it was not what you wanted.

We are not going to change the entire premise of the game because you don't like it.

Knight 1269 3811
  • 25 Sep '17
 Frise

You wanna hold your parry? Good for you, go play M&B or For Honor.

What you suggest has been discussed ad nauseum, look through the forums.

Knight 2307 4188
  • 24 Sep '17
 Runagate

Ironically, the lack of hit trading is one of the many reasons this game will not become another Chivalry.

Knight 1269 3811
  • 1
  • 24 Sep '17
 Frise

When two players attack at the same time, clashes happen. In clashes, the weapons collide and both players can keep comboing simultaneously. In these exchanges, the player who hits first flinchs their opponent, meaning there will never be a hit trade. Now, hitting first is not only dependent on your weapon's speed; what's most important is your footwork, aim and attack choice (and also your weapon's range). A decent player with a slow weapon will know how to position themselves so that they can hit the other player without getting hit themselves.

Actual hit trades will never be a thing because they ruin competitive play. They enable playstyles involving high-damage weapons purposefully trading hits with weaker weapons, which is ridiculous and not fun at all.

If you hit the opponent first, it's because you had better positioning, timing, aim, and/or your opponent didn't feint-to-parry. It's only logical that the other player gets punished.

Anyway, devs clearly stated that melee hit trades will never be a thing in Mordhau.

Duchess 6897 9885
  • 23 Sep '17
 Sir Zombie

Hittrading is bad and your idea is bad and realism is bad

Knight 2307 4188
Duke 196 836
  • 4
  • 22 Sep '17
 Ser_Thank_You

Ok I see 2 possible 'fixes' that would alleviate your concerns.

-Weapons do different damage at different parts of the swing.-

Problem - This leads to major inconsistency during fights. Even in a 1v1 duel, you can never be sure how much damage you just did to the enemy. Right now, I KNOW if I hit him in the head x times and in the torso y times, he will die. Period. If I hit him with a variable damage swing.....I have no idea (even if I wasn't intending to drag that strike, I still get 'punished')

or

-Minimal/no mouse movement during a swing-

Problem - This completely removes one of the key aspects of the game, lowers the skill ceiling significantly, removes any hope of 1vX, makes chambers impossible, makes ripostes difficult, and basically just go play For Honor.

Duchess 6897 9885
  • 22 Sep '17
 Sir Zombie

Not really nah