Mordhau

Held Block

954 302

@ZugZugNeverEnds said:

@Antoniokontos said:
i meant this post as a failed attempt of fixing the "Held block bad" thing by making all weapons have it mind you shields being better at it and costing more stamina than shields but it was just a little thing i thought at the time would have been to add more realism

don't be stupid. if all weapons had held block there would be no reason to put on a shield... like for fucks sake dude, come on! think man.... think; of the people below!

that was the point held block is broken so why not just make it were it all can be broken as one imagin the battles when 2 people are contantly holding block to avoid death despite neither taking the offensive

16 72
 Den

Instead of dismissing the statement for its simplicity, how about something that could be reasonably applied, even give the parry game some depth and variety among weapons while also making shields unique and less annoying. After all, if they are working on some change to the way shields work, may as well throw out some suggestions.
I do not think weapons should really get a held guard (at least not most of them), leave it to the shields... but it could be worth trying.

Call it the... Three-Stage Defense
Take this cruddy MSPaint visualization.
why not.png

  • Parry
    As all weapons currently have in a uniform fashion, a brief defensive window with the full benefit of preventing damage and negating the stamina drain. Shields could have their parry window made larger or smaller to differentiate them, instead of their only real differences currently being Stamina Negation.
  • Late Block
    What many panic-parrying players will often suffer. Take some/full damage and/or their stamina is screwed (no Stamina Drain Negation applied), and/or their path to a Held Guard is canceled and/or a Riposte is not available at this point. Ultimately it would do close to if not nothing, and is there just to space out the time to the...
  • Held Guard
    What the big shields have now, but this time it isn't something you can get to immediately; it'll take a moment after raising the shield. Depending on the shield or weapon, the stamina drain negation could be worse or just as good as a parry, or a limited amount of damage can get through a weapon's guard. Weapons in Held Guard mode do not get the same arrow-blocking benefit as a shield; they'll still hit you.

In practice, you can give different weapons and the shields different periods of time for these three stages, as well as some unique elements to their Held Guards to make them more unique. And if every weapon can hold their guard, you could even buff ranged weapons a bit to deal with the idea of everyone just holding up their weapon to block all arrows.

The many ever popular Two-Handed weapons with a standard Parry window and a large Late Block before getting to their Held Guard. Mostly standardized across anything 5 Points and up.
One-Handed weapons or weapons like the Quarterstaff could have a much larger Parry window and/or a smaller Late Block, allowing them to get to the Held Guard faster, even though they would suffer the most detriments in the Held mode. Maybe something like the Short Sword could have a really good Held Guard or superior Parry window to make it stand out from its competing 1-point weapons like the Dagger and Cleaver which most people gravitate to since they can spam those things.
Kite Shield with the narrowest Parry and/or the longest Late Block, meaning you need time to get that shield up and commit to a Held Guard, but it would have a much better Guard than weapons or smaller shields (it just can't raise that guard immediately).
Buckler with the widest Parry window, making it easy to Parry and Riposte, but you gotta pay those extra points for it and it would have the worst Held Guard.
The other shields somewhere in the middle between those two.

Again, while I think weapons should NOT have the Held Guard (most of them, a couple could use a held guard as a unique gimmick, like the Quarterstaff), the above could be a way to make Shields less of an annoyance, make each more diverse and give them different benefits with that multi-stage mechanic. If you're going to use a shield, either you time those parries (which would either be better or worse than using a weapon to parry) right just like everyone else, or you come into the fight with the shield already up.

57 26
  • 4 Aug
 Odd

This low-key what I was thinking,

When I first started playing the game.